I can't say that I've seen that behavior before, but would be curious to know what version of IE and Flash you're using so that I could try and replicate it on my end. Also, have you tried to insert any other web object videos (from another site, such as YouTube) within your course? Do those have the same behavior?
I am using IE Version 11.0.9600.16521. I have version 12,0,0,77 of FLASH installed.
I have embedded video using the insert video from a website option and used the YouTube embed code and from memory (I will test again today) they work well on IE. The only problem is that when you use that option of inserting video from a website you end up with it wrapped in flash code so it will not display on an iPad. That is why I went down the Insert a web object so that I could avoid the YouTube Flash code and be able to view the course on a Desktop as well as iPads.
Thanks for sending along the link - and I saw the behavior you described in IE11 (although the video opened and played automatically, I didn't have to download it) and it also happened in IE10 as well. I tested this in my own file with an MP4 that I found online and inserted it as a web object and that version opened normally in IE so I'd want to take a look at this video itself and try it - can you point me to where I could find one of the MP4s? Or share your Storyline project?
I am not satisfied with the low quality of the video that is output by the built in video compression in Articulate Storyline, even at the best quality (9) the videos are way degraded compared to the original. This is why I wanted to steer clear of Youtube too, as the video does lose quality when being embedded. I have attempted the work around found here: http://community.articulate.com/forums/p/25543/146055.aspx#146055
it does not bode well for my videos that are in 30fps (they flicker a little) I will keep on experimenting and maybe compressing my originals myself to try and make the "workaround" work better.
I guess I am stuck until Articulate allows videos to be a little less compressed.
I know a number of users mention implementing that method with success, but I don't know that I've ever heard them mention a particular frame rate that works best. You may want to try posting in that thread too in case they have additional ideas on how to work with the original video files. In regards to the compression issue, I'd also suggest sharing your thoughts on video compression (or compression in general) with our team in the form of a feature request.
Definitely keep us posted on how that goes, Daniel.
And just a quick note that replying via email attached your signature in the thread here. No worries though, this Peek video will show you how to remove it if desired!
Sorry you're having some trouble with your web object, John. What version of Storyline are you using? Mind sharing your file so I can test it on my machine?
Thanks for sharing that link and a copy of your file!
I took a look and saw the same thing that you mentioned and I was also able to replicate it with a new video. It seems to be an issue with how IE is reading the video file since you're embedding directly to the MP4 link. It's something I did share with our team, but you may also want to look at using a site such as Vimeo or Youtube to host the video too.
I saw you also posted here, so I'll link these two discussions. The overall size of your video file should be okay to insert directly into Storyline though - I've seen much larger! Keep in mind, that may change the playback speed but depending on where/how your users will be accessing it, it might work out just fine. Worth giving it a try and save you this trouble with IE11!
15 Replies
Hi John,
I can't say that I've seen that behavior before, but would be curious to know what version of IE and Flash you're using so that I could try and replicate it on my end. Also, have you tried to insert any other web object videos (from another site, such as YouTube) within your course? Do those have the same behavior?
Hi Ashley,
Thank you for your prompt reply, I will PM you the site for my Articulate published project and see how you go looking at it from there.
As soon as I am the office, I will send more information to you
Regards,
John Leeder
Hi Ashley,
I am using IE Version 11.0.9600.16521. I have version 12,0,0,77 of FLASH installed.
I have embedded video using the insert video from a website option and used the YouTube embed code and from memory (I will test again today) they work well on IE. The only problem is that when you use that option of inserting video from a website you end up with it wrapped in flash code so it will not display on an iPad. That is why I went down the Insert a web object so that I could avoid the YouTube Flash code and be able to view the course on a Desktop as well as iPads.
Hi John,
Thanks for sending along the link - and I saw the behavior you described in IE11 (although the video opened and played automatically, I didn't have to download it) and it also happened in IE10 as well. I tested this in my own file with an MP4 that I found online and inserted it as a web object and that version opened normally in IE so I'd want to take a look at this video itself and try it - can you point me to where I could find one of the MP4s? Or share your Storyline project?
Hi Ashley,
Thank you for your help and suggestions so far.
I am not satisfied with the low quality of the video that is output by the built in video compression in Articulate Storyline, even at the best quality (9) the videos are way degraded compared to the original. This is why I wanted to steer clear of Youtube too, as the video does lose quality when being embedded. I have attempted the work around found here: http://community.articulate.com/forums/p/25543/146055.aspx#146055
it does not bode well for my videos that are in 30fps (they flicker a little) I will keep on experimenting and maybe compressing my originals myself to try and make the "workaround" work better.
I guess I am stuck until Articulate allows videos to be a little less compressed.
Hi John,
I know a number of users mention implementing that method with success, but I don't know that I've ever heard them mention a particular frame rate that works best. You may want to try posting in that thread too in case they have additional ideas on how to work with the original video files. In regards to the compression issue, I'd also suggest sharing your thoughts on video compression (or compression in general) with our team in the form of a feature request.
I have attached pics of a video that will not play on IE but works fine on Firefox. This is a Articulate 360 program. Can you suggest a plan?
Hi Daniel,
Thanks for the images. Do you know what version of IE you're using? Where are you hosting the output?
I published your course for Web and uploaded to Tempshare here. That one worked for me in Edge and IE11. Can you give a test as well?
Thank you
I am on IE11 on our intranet
I will try again
Daniel LaCivita
Manager - Training and Compliance
Dassault Aircraft Services
Office:.........+ 1 302 322 7203
Mobile:...........+1 302 354 2251
New Castle Airport
191 N. DuPont Highway
New Castle, Delaware 19720
USA
das.falconjet.com
Definitely keep us posted on how that goes, Daniel.
And just a quick note that replying via email attached your signature in the thread here. No worries though, this Peek video will show you how to remove it if desired!
hi guys,
my experience is slightly similar. the web object i inserted wasn't a video but an online form we created and host.
online form loads fine in chrome but not on IE.
any ideas why ?
i am on version 11.0.9600.18816 to be specific
Sorry you're having some trouble with your web object, John. What version of Storyline are you using? Mind sharing your file so I can test it on my machine?
Hello
I'm experiencing the same problem.
TempShare link for previewing (Click on Ultrasound, then click Play arrow icon)
.story file attached as well.
Has there been a resolution to this issue?
Hi Karen,
Thanks for sharing that link and a copy of your file!
I took a look and saw the same thing that you mentioned and I was also able to replicate it with a new video. It seems to be an issue with how IE is reading the video file since you're embedding directly to the MP4 link. It's something I did share with our team, but you may also want to look at using a site such as Vimeo or Youtube to host the video too.
I saw you also posted here, so I'll link these two discussions. The overall size of your video file should be okay to insert directly into Storyline though - I've seen much larger! Keep in mind, that may change the playback speed but depending on where/how your users will be accessing it, it might work out just fine. Worth giving it a try and save you this trouble with IE11!
Thanks. I've embedded it and will do some testing.
This discussion is closed. You can start a new discussion or contact Articulate Support.