Pop-up layer only shows on first click

How do I get the Incorrect layer to pop up every time a wrong answer is clicked?

Here's what's happening now: The first time I select a wrong answer, the Incorrect layer pops up, but NOT for subsequent wrong answers—UNLESS I select the correct answer first (Correct layer pops up), THEN I select another wrong answer, the Incorrect layer will pop up one more time.

On the off-chance the user selects six incorrect answers in a row before finding the correct answer, I want the Incorrect layer to pop up EVERY time. These are pretty simple layers and triggers. Is the animation messing it up?

This is not a scored test; it is just a review exercise. Story file attached. Thanks!