10 Replies
Crystal Horn

Hi there, Katelin.  Here's what worked for me.  If I manipulate both of these Text options at the top of my theme colors, I consistently get the text on my buttons to be what color I want when adding new buttons.

Can you try changing the top dropdown to white as well, and let me know if that works on your buttons?  If not, share your file here with us, and we can have a closer look at the setup.  Thanks!