Elearning failure
Sep 18, 2014
Dear all,
I have been heavily involved in Elearning since 1998. During that period I experienced both failure and success. I have been involved as a client of Elearning and as an Elearning provider selling Elearning solutions tot he market. I am currently doing my doctorate in Human Resources Development using Elearning while focusing on the failure of Elearning and the reasons behind it. it is important to note that when we speak of failure we are not referring to absolute failure, but rather to the failure of Elearning to achieve a wide acceptance among human resources and training managers as it was intended to be. I believe that Elearning failure has been due four key areas: Poor design, badly structured content, medium of delivery, and the targeted audience.
I would really appreciate your input on the subject.
10 Replies
I agree with your points, but would add my own take:
Poor design - I would say failure of proper instructional design - in the past there's was a great amount of product which did not consider the learners' needs to be intrigued, interacted with, paced properly, challenged etc.
To my mind this is why many people in the training manager community are very wary.
JaF
I think there are several different types of failure. Obvious failure is easy to see; when results don't happen or if instructional material doesn't function correctly, etc. Then there are various levels of unnoticed failure. These are the types I see the most and technically, every single course has varying levels of failure. I use the term course to loosely apply to whatever instructional mechanism is being used.
I think these failures are due to a great lack of applied knowledge, creativity, basic design concepts, and competent instructional writing skills to name a few.
That being said, Hassan was speaking to failure to gain acceptance among HR folks and managers which I think is a very different argument than what I proposed because you can gain acceptance even with the biggest unnoticed failures. It would probably have more to do with obvious failure which I think in part could be due to poor salesmanship.
good move
I would say that most businesses fail to deploy training/learning, ANY training/learning correctly.
In many cases they will not discipline/retrain/re-locate people who "fail" at Quizzes and so on, and the training fails to tie itself to anything meaningful in the business.
I think a lot of eLearning now lags behind what people see on the Internet/TV - and because it is a "visual" medium, we set ourselves up to fail from the start in many instances when we still talk about "slides" and so on. It may not be correct to dismiss eLearning like that, but it's the perception of the learners that is important, and a lot of them do just that.
Success is a matter of how training is sold as part of a bigger picture, and if there's no motivation to actually learn, it's the same as being told to go to a football/soccer match when you hate football/soccer and have no reason to do so. You will enter the stadium demotivated, not really watch the match, and leave with a negative opinion. And then you are "forced" to go to the Annual Compliance vs. Process Departmental Football/Soccer match.
No wonder so much eLearning is a battle for sponsors, producers and learners!
I would really apprecite it if you could take a couple of minutes to answer the relevant survey below. I will make my research results available to the community so that all may benefit.
For elearning user: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/13gXhBBddADk40267i5MPq_E3NieVMDG7XfGrF60LZR8/viewform?c=0&w=1&usp=mail_form_link
For Elearning vendors: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1DsCm7NbZCKSvQTl11wgcas3bSUn4w-XJKpTDvNwhdlA/viewform?c=0&w=1&usp=mail_form_link
For organizations deployingelearning: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1Lx97TprGtBzydD_id4C_vUhxWNI4_zl2c95ag1sOq1w/viewform?c=0&w=1&usp=mail_form_link
For Learning Specialists : https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1klgA37AjBOqUKCFPNcjB7B40o_acCq5oEEyya-eNP54/viewform?c=0&w=1&usp=mail_form_link
Hassan, I see that six years have passed since your post. Would there be anything that you could share with regard to the outcomes of your survey?