Choice-Specific feedback on Storyline quiz questions doesn't display upon second review

I'm experiencing an issue with choice-specific feedback on multiple choice questions in Articulate Storyline. I have built a simple multiple choice quiz with feedback layers. When I take the quiz, everything functions as it should within the question slides. When I complete the quiz, I click Review Quiz, and I'm able to review the feedback as I should, with response-specific layers displaying for each quiz question. However, on the second attempt to review the quiz, feedback layers do not display. This is the case whether I pass or fail the quiz, attempt to re-take the quiz, or not. Feedback is visible on the first pass through the review, but never after. 

I have tried every kind of setting adjustment I can think of, especially all different settings for layer properties on the feedback layers. It doesn't matter if I have it set as a Quiz or Knowledge Check, and I've made sure to adjust layer properties settings in the Feedback Master, as well as on individual question slides. 

What's odd is that when I share the quiz file with my coworkers, one of them experiences the same issue I do, while the other 2 experience no issue. They are able to view feedback on every subsequent quiz review, whether in Preview mode or publishing to R360. 

Any suggestions on how to resolve this? Or thoughts on why some coworkers who download the file and make no changes to it, do not experience the issue?