Drag items snap back to wrong location after adding a trigger

Hi heroes,

I want to create a drag & activity with no wrong answers - users can drag items to a drop target, and the activity ends once they have X number of items on the drop target.

In Options, I checked "Return item to start point if dropped outside" to allow users to remove an item from the target and replace them. I created a counter variable and added triggers and conditions to each drag item, adjusting the counter.

The problem is, once I add the triggers to a drag item, it no longer snaps back to its original location, but to another spot (all items snap back to the same spot, overlapping). 

I attached an example of what I'm trying to do. Any help is appreciated - I'm not sure where to even start...

Thanks,

Merav