help with getting an object to show (change to normal state) when all buttons are visited

So it doesn't function properly...when I previewed the samplecopy file, a hand icon appears when you hover over the CTA and the second state shows when you click it.

Note: I wanted the text and green outline separate b/c of animations (I don't like the text to appear when the outline does), but will be OK with one object if we can get it to work.

Any ideas why this hand icon/trigger is present?  I even tried duplicating in a separate file and the same thing happened.