Where are all the comments?

I'm having this exact same problem: I'm receiving new comments via email, but when I log into Review, the comments aren't there in the "Current Version" of the course.

I suspect the issue has to do with publishing a new version of an existing course, while a SME is  actively working in the course in Review. That seemed to stick my SME's NEW comments permanently in the OLDER version of the course. I checked, and there they were in the older version. And if I publish several versions while a SME is in Review, their comments will be scattered throughout multiple older versions.

I can work around this anomaly, but it detracts from the usefulness of Review. Especially under very tight deadlines, I need to make changes and resolve comments almost immediately after they are posted by my SMEs. I often don't have the luxury to wait until every SME is done before I start making changes. Additionally, with multiple SMEs in Review at different times, I need to keep the "Current Version" in Review as up-to-date as possible. I can't just work in Rise and just publish a final version after everyone is done. I must show progress . . . and that is why I need to publish several versions in a short amount of time while multiple SMEs are in Review.

Sometimes it works, and sometimes it doesn't.