Photo versus illustrated characters
Hi everyone,
I have a question for everyone about their experience using photo or illustrated characters and graphics. My organization is at a bit of a crossroads right now where we're not sure what direction we want to take future online learning projects, in terms of the graphics.
We've done a number of projects using Articulate's illustrated modern characters and only using Articulate's stock library of illustrations and icons. The characters and illustrations are quite limited, especially for our purposes as a health non-profit (for example, the characters, from any set, lack people aged 60+). We're willing to purchase external character sets or access to graphics databases, but more importantly we need to first determine what the appropriate look and feel for these projects will be and the merits of both approaches.
My boss and I have different views; she expressed that she prefers real life photos in online learning, like photorealistic characters and photo stock images as they add a human element that she thinks mimics in-person learning. I have expressed my concern that photorealistic characters as they can look quite corny and dated. My preference is more towards illustrative characters and vector images as these can give our work a more modern feel. I am also concerned that the photos of people may be more distracting as human faces are quite attention grabbing.
I've tried to do research on this topic to determine the value of either photo or illustrative images, in terms of education, and I could not find anything in a google or academic database search. From what I have heard from other instructional designers, this choice usually has to do with brand preferences. While I am in the process of working with others on our team about brand preference, I wanted to open this question up to the e-learning heroes community to find out what others think about this question of photos versus illustrations. Which do you use in your projects and why? Which is more advantageous, pedagogically and graphically?
I look forward to hearing from others.
Thank you,
Jessica