I was told that instead of using All of the Above and None of the Above for multiple choice questions, that I should use only None. Is there a reason why?
(In your question you are talking about "none" as an alternative to All of the above/None of the above....er..unless it involves algebra, I can't see how this answer type could serve as a better alternative: )
Presuming this isn't a technical question, I'll quote an article I've recently read regarding multiple choice questions.
Avoid using the alternative ‘all the above’ and use ‘none of the above’ with caution.
'All of the above’ makes it possible to answer the question on the basis of partial information
if there is only one correct answer, and a student notes that two alternatives are correct, ‘All the
above’ must be the answer. Similarly, a student can detect ‘All the above’ as a wrong answer if
he/she recognises another alternative as incorrect.
‘None of the above’ — when used as the right answer in a correct answer type item — tends to measure nothing more than the ability to detect wrong answers (with no guarantee that a student knows a correct response to the question). \
Click here for search results for "All of the Above and None of the Above for multiple choice questions"
Guidelines for writing good multiple choice questions - click here.
Pdf with a in-depth analysis of these question types from a psychological perspective.
1 Reply
Hi Inez,
(In your question you are talking about "none" as an alternative to All of the above/None of the above....er..unless it involves algebra, I can't see how this answer type could serve as a better alternative: )
Presuming this isn't a technical question, I'll quote an article I've recently read regarding multiple choice questions.
Avoid using the alternative ‘all the above’ and use ‘none of the above’ with caution.
- 'All of the above’ makes it possible to answer the question on the basis of partial information
if there is only one correct answer, and a student notes that two alternatives are correct, ‘All theabove’ must be the answer. Similarly, a student can detect ‘All the above’ as a wrong answer if
he/she recognises another alternative as incorrect.
Click here for search results for "All of the Above and None of the Above for multiple choice questions"
Guidelines for writing good multiple choice questions - click here.
Pdf with a in-depth analysis of these question types from a psychological perspective.
Kind Regards,
Rutwin
This discussion is closed. You can start a new discussion or contact Articulate Support.