audio recordings: Audacity vs. in-line AS
Sep 10, 2015
should actors record directly in AS or on their devices (e.g. iPhones) and email the audio files (or record in Audacity)?
AS direct – pros:
no fuss with file name systems,
no importing files to replace placeholders,
so possibly time saved,
visual/learning context clear to actors/speakers, who work thru & see each scene/slide, finding their lines in the “Notes” and reading them aloud,
the speakers have easy access too to any placeholders that may serve as inspiration for the designers’ desired intonation, etc,
so perhaps more appropriate final vocal expression
AS direct – cons:
no noise filter feature (like in Audacity)
no volume equalizer for overly soft recordings (like in Audacity)
not as easy to make edits (easier / more features in Audacity)
not all actors may have physical access to computer with AS installed, i.e. may to always be possible
in this vein, Audacity is free and accessible for actors anywhere, anytime to record in
vs. hefty AS pricetag
3 Replies
Hi Jonathan.
Sorry for the late response. I would definitely lean towards allowing the voice actor to use their preferred method of recording. You can publish your Storyline presentation minus the audio and let them view that. You can also publish your presentation for Word and include your slide notes if you are using them to direct the actor.
The other issue is around licensing. Articulate Storyline's license if for one user on up to two computers. It doesn't really make sense, in my mind, to pay for a license for occasional or one off use.
The voice actor, if they have been doing this for a while, should already have tools and a methodology that you probably don't want to get in the way of by introducing a piece of software they may not be familiar with. Hope that helps!
As someone who has been a professional voiceover for about a decade and, over the last three years, has used Articulate Products, almost daily, I agree with Justin. The voice actor has a lot to focus on without the hassle of learning a new tool like AS: their error rate, giving an interesting read, hard-to-pronounce words, etc. I'd let them do what's best for them.
That said, I have had very little luck with using low-quality MP3s in storyline. I have to use WAVs or rip MP3s that are 128kbps. Not even 48kpbs is good enough in many cases. See the attachment for the Audacity screen.
Also, keep in mind that many full-time voice actors will have professional-grade studios that exceed the capabilities of both Audacity and Storyline. Myself included. They need to be able to use their own environment so they can provide you with the best possible sound.
Blessings to you and loved ones.
Thanks for popping in to share Ron :)
This discussion is closed. You can start a new discussion or contact Articulate Support.