Seeking Optimal Audio Specs for Importing to Storyline
Jun 14, 2012
Hi, all! Apologies if this query is answered elsewhere in the Forums, but I couldn't find it.
I'm going to be importing individual audio clips onto my Storyline slides. I read the tutorial about audio that includes the list of supported formats, but here's my concern: in Captivate, for example, they invite you to import Mp3 or WAV files. But the reality is, since Mp3 is a compressed audio format, when you publish a Captivate project with Mp3s on the slides, the publish process compresses the Mp3s again, resulting in loss of audio quality. I pointed this out to them a while back, and I don't think it's resolved yet. Would the same be true of Storyline? Of course, I'm looking to balance good audio quality with minimizing project file size. The Storyline courseware will be played on both PCs and iPads by the client. Is WAV the optimal format to import, despite its size, since presumably the Storyline publish process will perform a compression? Or is another audio format better? Or is Storyline so clever that it doesn't compress the audio files during publish? This is my first Storyline project for a client, so I have not yet had experience with lengthy courses. These courses will probably be about 50-60 slides each, so they're not gigantic. Any guidance would be much appreciated. Many thanks!
4 Replies
My state of mind has always been to import file types that will offer the best compression results - wav, bmp, png, etc - and let the software do the compression. SL has a great compression capability.
Flash used to actually make larger swfs when jpgs were imported vs bmp.
I always use MP3 for audio and have had no problems with loss of quality.
Actually here is an example if you want to listen for yourself - there is no audio on the first slide but this example has both voice narration and computer generated audio all done in MP3.
https://dl.dropbox.com/u/73851/Branching%20example%20output/story.html
Thanks for the input, folks! And a gorgeous sample, Nancy! Love the visuals. Thanks for sharing. I've played a bit with both Mp3 and WAV, but not on a big project yet. Sound wise I do prefer the WAV but agree that a good quality Mp3 does still sound pretty good after publish as well. So I guess I'll go with WAV on this project and it for any reason the file size becomes an issue, I can always convert.
PS--cool factoid about the flash publish, Bill!
This discussion is closed. You can start a new discussion or contact Articulate Support.